Chapter 3: Dining with Sinners


Jesus and the Pharisees: A Conflict of Kingdoms

A Historical Novel Based on the Gospels


(Matthew 9:9–13; Mark 2:13–17; Luke 5:27–32)

The sun had begun its slow descent over Capernaum, casting a warm golden hue across the dusty streets. Jesus walked along the road near the customs booth, where men lined up to pay their taxes under the stern gaze of the tax collectors. The people passed quickly, heads bowed, hearts burning with silent hatred for those who served the Roman oppressors.

Levi sat there, pen scratching against parchment, counting silver coins into neat piles. His robes were expensive, but his eyes were tired and empty. Then, suddenly, he felt a presence before him. Looking up, he saw a man standing there – eyes filled with strength, purpose, and a kindness Levi had never known.

“Follow me.” (Matthew 9:9)

The words were simple, yet they thundered into the silent chambers of Levi’s soul. Without a word, he rose, leaving behind his table, his records, and his coins. He followed Jesus down the road, his heart pounding with freedom he had never tasted.

That evening, Levi hosted a great feast in his house. The aroma of roasting lamb, spiced wine, and freshly baked bread drifted out into the street. Reclining around the table were tax collectors like him, men shunned by society, and others labelled “sinners” – prostitutes, merchants who broke Sabbath laws, men who lived on the edges of polite religion.

In the centre sat Jesus, speaking with gentleness yet authority, laughter and wonder lighting the faces of those around Him. For once, they felt dignity rather than scorn.

But outside, shadows lingered. Pharisees watched through the latticed windows, their robes glowing white in the lamplight, their faces dark with disapproval.

They approached Jesus’ disciples standing near the entrance.

“Why does your teacher eat with tax collectors and sinners?” they asked, disdain dripping from every word. (Matthew 9:11)

Jesus, overhearing them, turned from the table. His gaze met theirs with piercing clarity.

“Those who are well have no need of a physician, but those who are sick.” (Matthew 9:12)

He stepped closer to the doorway, the lamplight falling across His face, revealing eyes both tender and fierce.

“Go and learn what this means: ‘I desire mercy, and not sacrifice.’ For I came not to call the righteous, but sinners.” (Matthew 9:13)

The Pharisees stood silent, the words of Hosea cutting through their robes of ritual purity into hearts of stone. Without waiting for their reply, Jesus turned back to the table, sitting once more among the outcasts, the rejected, the wounded – His presence making them whole.

That night, as laughter and song rose from Levi’s house into the Galilean sky, the Pharisees walked away in silence, their minds swirling with confusion, jealousy, and growing hatred. For in that house, they had seen a glimpse of a kingdom their hearts could not comprehend – a kingdom where holiness embraced sinners, and mercy sat down to dine with the broken.