How Does Religious Freedom Work in Pluralistic Societies?

,

Political and Legal Questions

1. Introduction

Religious freedom is a foundational principle in pluralistic societies, protecting individuals and groups to practice, change, or reject religion without coercion. This analysis examines:

  • Legal frameworks for religious freedom
  • Philosophical justifications
  • Challenges in pluralistic contexts
  • Case studies illustrating tensions and accommodations

2. Defining Religious Freedom

2.1 International Standards

Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), Article 18 (1948):

“Everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion; this right includes freedom to change his religion or belief, and freedom… to manifest his religion or belief in teaching, practice, worship and observance.” (UN, 1948)

2.2 Key Dimensions

  • Forum internum: internal freedom of belief, absolute.
  • Forum externum: external manifestation (worship, dress, symbols, proselytism), subject to limitations for public safety, order, health, or morals (ICCPR, Article 18).

3. Philosophical Justifications

3.1 Liberalism

John Locke (1689)

Advocated toleration as a political necessity, excluding atheists and Catholics in his context, yet foundational for modern religious liberty (Locke, Letter Concerning Toleration).

3.2 John Stuart Mill (1859)

Freedom of conscience essential for individual autonomy, truth-seeking, and social progress (On Liberty).

3.3 Rawlsian Pluralism

John Rawls (1993) argues for “overlapping consensus”: diverse moral and religious doctrines agree on political principles ensuring freedom for all.

4. Legal Frameworks in Pluralistic Societies

4.1 Constitutional Protections

United States

  • First Amendment: Establishment Clause prohibits state religion; Free Exercise Clause protects religious practice.
  • Strict scrutiny applied when laws burden religious practice (Sherbert v. Verner, 1963; RFRA, 1993).

United Kingdom

  • No codified constitution but rights protected under Human Rights Act 1998, incorporating ECHR Article 9.
  • Establishment of the Church of England coexists with freedom of religion for all.

India

  • Constitution Article 25–28 guarantees religious freedom while empowering state intervention for social reform (e.g. banning untouchability, temple entry laws).

4.2 International Law

  • ICCPR Article 18 protects belief and practice, subject to limitations.
  • European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), Article 9 similar, with ECtHR jurisprudence balancing religious manifestation and public order (Evans, 2001).

5. Challenges in Pluralistic Societies

5.1 Balancing Competing Rights

Case: Religious Dress Codes

  • France’s 2004 ban on conspicuous religious symbols in public schools (Law 2004-228) justified by laïcité (state secularism) but criticised for restricting Muslim women’s freedom (Bowen, 2007).

ECtHR: Dahlab v. Switzerland (2001)

Upheld ban on headscarf for primary teacher, citing influence on young children’s religious development.

5.2 Minority Religions and Equality

Case: Sikhs in the UK

Legal exemptions allowing turbans instead of helmets on motorbikes (Motor-Cycle Crash Helmets (Religious Exemption) Act 1976) illustrate accommodation balancing safety law with religious freedom (Ballard, 1994).

5.3 Anti-Conversion Laws

In some pluralistic countries (e.g. India), anti-conversion laws restrict proselytism to protect community harmony, raising concerns over freedom of belief (Robinson & Clarke, 2003).

5.4 Blasphemy and Hate Speech

Balancing Free Speech and Religious Respect

  • Denmark and Iceland abolished blasphemy laws (2017 and 2018 respectively).
  • Pakistan enforces strict blasphemy laws with death penalty potential (Hussain, 2019).

6. Models of Religious Freedom in Pluralistic Societies

6.1 Secular Neutrality

State remains neutral between religions, e.g. US model (Nussbaum, 2008).

6.2 Laïcité

Strict separation, restricting public religious expression to preserve secular public space, e.g. France (Baubérot, 2000).

6.3 Multicultural Accommodation

Actively accommodates diverse religious practices in public sphere, e.g. Canada (Kymlicka, 1995).

7. Benefits of Religious Freedom in Pluralistic Societies

  • Protects minority rights against majoritarian imposition.
  • Promotes social peace by reducing resentment and marginalisation.
  • Fosters moral and spiritual diversity, enriching public discourse.

8. Critiques and Limitations

8.1 Asymmetry

Majority religions often enjoy implicit privileges despite formal equality (Modood, 2013).

8.2 Secular Bias

Critics argue secular liberal frameworks privilege individualist forms of religion over communal or orthodox expressions (Casanova, 1994).

9. Conclusion

How does religious freedom work in pluralistic societies?

  • Legal frameworks and constitutional protections uphold individual and collective rights to believe, worship, and manifest religion.
  • Tensions arise balancing religious freedom with equality, public order, and secularism.
  • Effective pluralistic religious freedom requires:
    • Equal protection for all religions
    • Accommodation of diverse practices within shared legal limits
    • Dialogue to manage conflicts over competing rights

Thus, religious freedom is both foundational to and continuously negotiated within pluralistic societies.

10. References

  • Ballard, R. (1994). Desh Pardesh: The South Asian Presence in Britain. Hurst.
  • Baubérot, J. (2000). Histoire de la laïcité en France. Presses Universitaires de France.
  • Bowen, J. R. (2007). Why the French Don’t Like Headscarves. Princeton University Press.
  • Casanova, J. (1994). Public Religions in the Modern World. University of Chicago Press.
  • Evans, C. (2001). Freedom of Religion under the European Convention on Human Rights. Oxford University Press.
  • Hussain, A. (2019). Blasphemy Laws in Pakistan: A Historical Overview. Islamic Studies, 58(2), 165–191.
  • Kymlicka, W. (1995). Multicultural Citizenship. Oxford University Press.
  • Locke, J. (1689). A Letter Concerning Toleration.
  • Modood, T. (2013). Multiculturalism. Polity Press.
  • Nussbaum, M. (2008). Liberty of Conscience. Basic Books.
  • Pandey, G. (1990). The Construction of Communalism in Colonial North India. Oxford University Press.
  • Parker, G. (1997). The Thirty Years’ War. Routledge.
  • Rawls, J. (1993). Political Liberalism. Columbia University Press.
  • Riley-Smith, J. (2005). The Crusades: A History. Yale University Press.
  • Robinson, R., & Clarke, S. (2003). Religious Conversion in India. Oxford University Press.
  • Tyerman, C. (2006). God’s War: A New History of the Crusades. Belknap Press.
  • United Nations. (1948). Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
Home