The Saying: The Blind Leading the Blind

1. Title of the Saying

The Blind Leading the Blind

2. Scripture Reference(s)

  • Matthew 15:14 (M)
  • Luke 6:39 (L)

3. Thematic Category

Short Parabolic Sayings / Similitudes; False Guidance; Spiritual Discernment; Leadership and Accountability

4. Saying Summary

Jesus offers a stark warning:

“Can a blind man lead a blind man? Will they not both fall into a pit?” (Luke 6:39)
“They are blind guides. And if the blind lead the blind, both will fall into a pit.” (Matt. 15:14)

This proverbial saying highlights the danger of following spiritually blind leaders, particularly religious figures who lack discernment, truth, or humility.

5. Cultural and Historical Context

In Jewish culture, spiritual leaders were expected to guide others in the way of God, much like shepherds or teachers. The term “blind” was used by prophets (e.g., Isaiah 56:10; 59:10) to describe leaders who were corrupt, ignorant, or self-deceived.

Jesus applies this metaphor to the Pharisees and scribes, who had elevated tradition over God’s commandments (Matt. 15:1–9). Their failure to perceive spiritual truth made them dangerous guides, not reliable teachers.

The imagery of falling into a pit reflects both physical danger and moral ruin—a metaphor for destruction caused by blind misleadership.

6. Literary Form and Structure

  • Type: Similitude / metaphorical warning
  • Structure: Rhetorical question → obvious consequence
  • Techniques: Irony, contrast, visual metaphor, allusion to Old Testament imagery

7. Theological Meaning and Kingdom Implications

The saying teaches that:

  • Spiritual blindness is contagious—if leaders are deceived, their followers are endangered.
  • The Kingdom requires discernment, truth, and clarity, not empty religiosity.
  • False teaching and legalism distort God’s intent and can lead people away from salvation.
  • Jesus calls for leaders who can see clearly, who are rooted in divine truth and humble obedience.

8. Moral and Ethical Lessons

  • Leaders must ensure they are spiritually awake and morally aligned with God’s Word.
  • Believers must be cautious about whom they follow and trust.
  • Critically examining religious authority is not rebellion—it is wisdom.
  • Blind religiosity, without repentance or grace, is hazardous to communities.

9. Jesus’ Interpretation or Explanation

While brief, the saying is situated within broader teachings:

  • In Matthew 15, Jesus critiques the Pharisees for nullifying God’s Word with human traditions.
  • He labels them “blind guides” (v. 14) and tells His disciples to leave them, implying total spiritual misdirection.

This interpretation is sharpened by context—Jesus uses the metaphor to rebuke religious hypocrisy and redirect His followers to the true nature of God’s Kingdom.

10. Application for Contemporary Readers

  • Encourages discernment in choosing spiritual mentors, teachers, and traditions.
  • Warns against uncritical submission to authority, especially where the Word of God is compromised.
  • Reminds church leaders to pursue clarity, humility, and alignment with Scripture.
  • Empowers believers to walk in truth and accountability, not passive conformity.

11. Comparative Insights and Scholarly Commentary

  • Augustine saw the blind leading the blind as a picture of self-righteous preachers without inward transformation.
  • Calvin warned that false confidence in external forms of religion blinds both leaders and people.
  • Craig Blomberg views the saying as a direct indictment of Pharisaic legalism, highlighting the peril of empty rule-following.
  • N.T. Wright notes the phrase expresses Jesus’ prophetic critique of Israel’s leadership, who had lost their way and led others astray.
  • R.T. France emphasises that the consequence is mutual ruin—both leader and follower fall together.

12. Cross-References

  • Isaiah 56:10 – “Israel’s watchmen are blind…”
  • John 9:39–41 – Jesus speaks of spiritual blindness and accountability
  • 2 Peter 2:1–2 – Warning against false teachers who lead many astray
  • Proverbs 4:19 – “The way of the wicked is like deep darkness…”

13. Key Quotes and Phrases

  • “Can a blind man lead a blind man?” (Luke 6:39)
  • “Will they not both fall into a pit?”
  • “They are blind guides.” (Matt. 15:14)
  • “If the blind lead the blind…”
Home