The Parable of the New Cloth and New Wineskins

, ,

1. Title of the Parable

The Parable of the New Cloth and New Wineskins

2. Scripture Reference(s)

  • Matthew 9:16–17 (M)
  • Mark 2:21–22 (Mk)
  • Luke 5:36–39 (L)

3. Thematic Category

Discipleship and Faith; Renewal; Covenant Transformation; Receptivity to Change

4. Parable Summary

Jesus compares His message and ministry to new fabric and new wine. He states that:

  • No one patches an old garment with a new piece of cloth, because it will shrink and worsen the tear.
  • Similarly, no one pours new wine into old wineskins, or the skins will burst and both will be lost. Instead, new wine must be put into fresh wineskins.

Luke’s account adds: “No one after drinking old wine desires new, for he says, ‘The old is good.’”

Jesus uses these parables to explain why His disciples do not fast like those of John or the Pharisees—His presence inaugurates a new reality that cannot be confined within old religious structures.

5. Cultural and Historical Context

In the ancient world, unshrunk cloth would pull away from an older garment when washed, worsening the damage. Similarly, wineskins made from animal hide would become brittle over time. New wine, which continues to ferment and expand, required fresh, flexible containers.

Jesus spoke these parables during a time of heightened religious tension, where legalism and ritual observance often clashed with His message of grace, transformation, and Kingdom inauguration.

6. Literary Form and Structure

  • Type: Twin metaphorical parables / illustrative analogies
  • Structure: Common-sense proverb → spiritual application
  • Techniques: Metaphor, contrast, everyday imagery, implied critique of rigid religiosity

7. Theological Meaning and Kingdom Implications

These parables teach that:

  • Jesus’ message of the Kingdom is new, transformative, and dynamic.
  • Old religious systems (like Pharisaic legalism) cannot contain the new reality Jesus brings.
  • Discipleship requires a new internal structure—a renewed heart, not just outward conformity.
  • The Kingdom demands flexibility, openness, and spiritual renewal.

The old and new are not merely chronological but categorically different in nature and effect.

8. Moral and Ethical Lessons

  • We must avoid trying to force the Gospel into outdated or incompatible frameworks.
  • Religious tradition, when hardened, can obstruct spiritual growth and receptivity.
  • Discipleship involves not only external change but a fundamental reorientation of heart and mind.
  • Genuine faith is adaptive, renewing, and open to God’s unfolding work.

9. Jesus’ Interpretation or Explanation

While Jesus does not offer a formal interpretation, His point is implicit and made clear by context:

  • His presence signals the arrival of the bridegroom (Matt. 9:15), thus old forms of mourning and fasting are temporarily inappropriate.
  • He warns that new life in the Spirit cannot be squeezed into the moulds of old religion.

Luke 5:39 adds a sobering insight—people often resist the new, preferring the familiarity of the old, even when it’s inadequate.

10. Application for Contemporary Readers

  • Encourages Christians to embrace renewal rather than cling rigidly to tradition.
  • Warns the Church against legalistic or outdated frameworks that hinder the Gospel.
  • Promotes spiritual flexibility and openness to God’s transformative work.
  • Challenges believers to evaluate whether their lives, systems, and ministries are capable of containing the living wine of the Kingdom.

11. Comparative Insights and Scholarly Commentary

  • Augustine saw the wineskins as the soul, which must be renewed to hold God’s Spirit.
  • John Calvin emphasised that Gospel freedom could not be restrained by ceremonial laws.
  • Craig Blomberg highlights that the point is not chronological but structural incompatibility—newness must not be housed in old systems.
  • N.T. Wright links this to the end of the Old Covenant system and the dawn of Messianic fulfilment.
  • R.T. France notes the parable is a critique of religious rigidity, calling for spiritual elasticity to welcome Jesus’ Kingdom.

12. Cross-References

  • Ezekiel 36:26 – “I will give you a new heart and a new spirit”
  • Romans 7:6 – “Now we serve in the new way of the Spirit…”
  • 2 Corinthians 5:17 – “If anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation”
  • Galatians 5:1 – “For freedom Christ has set us free”

13. Key Quotes and Phrases

  • “No one puts a piece of unshrunk cloth on an old garment…” (Matt. 9:16)
  • “New wine must be put into fresh wineskins.” (Luke 5:38)
  • “And no one after drinking old wine desires new…” (Luke 5:39)
  • “The old is good.” (Luke 5:39)
Home