Historical Timeline: Development of Beliefs About Jesus
1️⃣ Before Jesus (1000 BC – 1 AD)
Judaism
- 1000–400 BC – Hebrew prophets predict a coming Messiah (earthly king, restorer).
- Messiah expected to bring:
- world peace
- ingathering of exiles
- rebuilt Temple
- universal knowledge of God
- 400–1 BC – “Intertestamental period”; no prophets; messianic expectations become political.
Impact:
Judaism enters the time of Jesus expecting earthly restoration, not Divine incarnation.
2️⃣ Life of Jesus (c. 4 BC – 30 AD)
Christianity
- Jesus claims:
- divine authority
- fulfilment of the Law
- kingdom of God (Divine realm)
- Performs miracles, gathers disciples.
- Crucifixion (c. 30 AD).
- Early Christians proclaim resurrection and ascension.
Judaism
- Jewish leaders reject Jesus as Messiah because:
- Roman rule remains
- no political restoration
- no Temple rebuilding
- no universal peace
Impact:
Christianity and Judaism diverge immediately over the definition of Messiah.
3️⃣ Early Christian Movement (30–100 AD)
Christianity
- 30–50 AD: Apostles preach Jesus as:
- Son of God
- Divine Word
- risen Messiah
- 50–100 AD: Gospels and letters written.
- Jesus becomes central to salvation and Divine Realm transfer.
Judaism
- Rejects Christian claims.
- Views Jesus as:
- failed messiah claimant
- executed by Rome
Impact:
Judaism maintains Earth-based messianic expectations; Christianity moves to Divine revelation.
4️⃣ Judaism Solidifies Post-Temple (70–200 AD)
- 70 AD – Second Temple destroyed by Rome.
- Rabbis re-form Judaism without a Temple.
- Christianity seen as the group that “went another way.”
- Jewish writings focus on Torah, ethics, and future political Messiah.
Impact:
Judaism defines itself against Christian claims to preserve identity under Roman rule.
5️⃣ Christian Theology Matures (100–325 AD)
- Early church fathers formalise beliefs:
- Jesus is divine
- Trinity develops
- Cross = salvation
- 325 AD – Council of Nicaea confirms Jesus’ divinity.
Impact:
Christianity becomes a strictly Divine-realm religion centred entirely on Jesus.
6️⃣ Pre-Islamic Arabia (200–600 AD)
Arabia exposed to:
- Jewish tribes
- Christian groups (often heretical sects)
- Pagan religions
Important:
Many Christian groups in Arabia denied Jesus’ divinity → this influences emerging Islamic correction.
7️⃣ Rise of Islam (610–632 AD)
Islam
- Qur’an affirms:
- Jesus’ virgin birth
- his miracles
- his ascension
- his role as Messiah
- his second coming
- Qur’an denies:
- Jesus’ divinity
- the crucifixion
- Positions Jesus as a restoring prophet, not divine but honoured.
Impact:
Islam forms a middle position:
Divine echoes (miracles, virgin birth) + Earth-realm monotheism (not divine).
8️⃣ After Islam (700–1000 AD)
Christianity
- Emphasises cross, resurrection, Trinity.
- Missionary expansion across Europe.
Judaism
- Holds Jesus to be a historical figure but not Messiah.
- Develops Talmudic commentary that includes debates about false messiahs.
Islam
- Spreads rapidly.
- Jesus becomes central in Islamic end-times doctrine.
🔍 Summary: Why They Differ (Timeline Logic)
| Period | Judaism | Christianity | Islam |
|---|---|---|---|
| Before Jesus | Earthly Messiah expected | — | — |
| During Jesus | Rejected His claims | Accepted Him as Divine Messiah | — |
| 30–100 AD | Solidified rejection | Resurrection theology formed | — |
| 70–325 AD | Self-definition after Temple | Trinity + divinity shaped | — |
| 610–632 AD | Earlier position maintained | — | Adopted partial Christian view but denied divinity |